Sub-theme 29: Social Evaluations: Antecedents, Outcomes and the Process of Social Construction

Alexandre B. Bitektine, Concordia University, Canada
Patrick Haack, HEC Lausanne, Switzerland
Anastasiya Zavyalova, Rice University, USA
Session I: Thursday, July 04, 11:00 to 12:30, 50 George Square - G.06
Introduction & Kick-off
Chair: Alex Bitektine
Riccardo Fini, Julien Jourdan, Markus Perkmann and Laura Toschi
Who gets admitted? The gatekeeper effect in peer accreditation
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Brian Reschke
Brian P. Reschke and Taeya M. Howell
Who gets ‘to guru’? The valuation of multiple audience engagement as bids for brokerage
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Julien Jourdan
Session II: Thursday, July 04, 14:00 to 15:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Legitimacy 1 - Room: 50 George Square - G.06
Chair: Patrick Haack
Melanie Eichhorn, Johannes Jahn and Rolf Brühl
Attributed motives, institutional pressure and their effects on organizational legitimacy judgments
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): David J. Langley, Chee-Wee Tan & Jan-Willem Tel
Xiaoyu Zhou and Xiyi Yang
The parable of the prodigal son: How category taken-for-grantedness affects audiences’ evaluation of organizational nonconformity
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Melanie Eichhorn, Johannes Jahn & Rolf Brühl
David Langley, Chee-Wee Tan and Jan-Willem Tel
Unraveling the effects of organizations’ response strategies on online social disapproval
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Xiaoyu Zhou & Xiyi Yang
Parallel Stream B: Stigma 1 - Room: 50 George Square - G.01
Chair: Annie Zavyalova
Tiffany D. Johnson and Kisha Lashley
Moral crusades: A theory of how audiences stigmatize organizational categories
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Eric Patton
Jan Lodge and Jennifer Howard-Grenville
From paralysis to cutting out the bad apple: Navigating organizational stigma in the aftermath of the Grenfell Tower tragedy
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Kisha Lashley & Tiffany Johnson
Eric Patton
The social construction of illness: Judging behaviors in the workplace
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Jan Lodge & Jennifer Howard-Grenville
Session III: Friday, July 05, 09:00 to 10:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Framing - Room: 50 George Square - G.06
Chair: Patrick Haack
Gerry McNamara
Irrational exuberance? Investor evaluations in response to CEO positive framing of acquisition announcements
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Cyrus Dioun
Halil Sabanci
The Authentic Appeal of the Corrupt Political Leader: Extrinsic Rewards, Authenticity, and Populist Rhetoric
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Wei Shi & Gerry McNamara
Cyrus Dioun
When it's good to be bad: Rewarding deviance in marijuana markets
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Halil Ibrahim Sabanci
Parallel Stream B: Status 1 - Room: 50 George Square - G.01
Chair: Alex BItektine
Leonard Schmidt and Thijs A. Velema
How mobility of individuals shapes organizational status
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Fabrizio Castellucci, Aneesh Datar & Azusa Nakamura
Déborah Philippe, David Zajtmann, François Collet and Alain Debenedetti
The emergence, institutionalization, and evolution of a status order: A study of the French high-end fashion field
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Leonard Schmidt & Thijs Velema
Azusa Nakamura, Aneesh Datar and Fabrizio Castellucci
Walking on a tight rope: How social actors balance creativity and familiarity when they become high-status?
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Déborah Philippe, David Zajtmann, François Collet & Alain Debenedetti
Session IV: Friday, July 05, 11:00 to 12:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Stigma 2 - Room: 50 George Square - G.06
Chair: Annie Zavyalova
Helena Pinto de Sousa, Martina Montauti and Luis Diestre
Hypocrite or first among equals? Performance effects of impression management tactics in stigmatized categories
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Karen D.W. Patterson & Jo-Ellen Pozner
Kim Clark and Yuan Li
A theory of organizational event-stigma
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Helena Pinto de Sousa
Karen Patterson and Jo-Ellen Pozner
Evaluating the Teflon Actor: The Role of Audience Cognition on the Process of Stigmatization
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Kim Clark & Yuan Li
Parallel Stream B: Reputation - Room: 50 George Square - G.01
Chair: Alex Bitektine
Jaegoo Lim, E. Geoffrey Love and Michael Bednar
Changing of the guards: The impact of CEO succession on corporate reputation
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Joel B. Carnevale & Lei Huang
Simone Mariconda, Patrick Haack and Michael Etter
Gone viral: How prior exposure and perceived support influence the effects of fake news on reputation judgments about organizations
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Jaegoo Lim, E. Geoffrey Love & Michael K. Bednar
Session V: Friday, July 05, 14:00 to 15:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Experiment - Room: 50 George Square - G.06
Chair: Patrick Haack
Anna Jasinenko, Fabian Christandl and Timo Meynhardt
In fair markets, there is no unfair business! And no responsible consumption?
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Wiley Wakeman, Philip Yang & Celia Moore
Alexandre B. Bitektine and Fei Song
Exploring antecedents of social evaluations: The effects of pricing on legitimacy, reputation and status
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Anna Jasinenko, Fabian Christandl & Timo Meynhardt
Wiley Wakeman, Philip Yang and Celia Moore
Selecting deviants: Rule breaking as a signal of one’s communal value
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Alex Bitektine & Fei Song
Parallel Stream B: Investor Reactions - Room: 50 George Square - G.01
Chair: Annie Zavyalova
Orit Shamai, Itzhak Harpaz and Raphael Snir
Heavy work investors’ perceptions of their affective states
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Derek J. Harmon & Eunice Rhee
Matt C. Hersel and Ashley Gangloff
Mixed messages in the aftermath of misconduct: Investor reactions to response sequences following fraud
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Orit Shamai, Itzhak Harpaz & Raphael Snir
Derek J. Harmon and Eunice Rhee
Constructing new valuation metrics: Entrepreneurial arguments and stock market reactions in nascent markets
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Matt C. Hersel & Ashley Gangloff
Session VI: Saturday, July 06, 09:00 to 10:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Status 2 - Room: 50 George Square - G.06
Chair: Annie Zavyalova
Andrea Cavicchini
The external influences on organizational culture: CEO awards and biased perceptions of organizational culture
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Ben W. Lewis & W. Chad Carlos
Ben Lewis and W. Chad Carlos
Does marginal inclusion on a ranking enhance firm value?
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Emmanuel Kypraios
Parallel Stream B: Legitimacy 2 - Room: 50 George Square - G.01
Chair: Patrick Haack
Ali Ghods, Antonin Ricard and Bénédicte Aldebert
Reconceptualizing the measurement of legitimacy: An approach and empirical validation
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Keyan Lai
Julita Majczyk
Enhancing a leader’s legitimacy in press
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Ali Ghods
Keyan Lai
Organizational Stigma and Legitimacy: Evaluating a Chinese Firm in the UK’s Hinkley Nuclear Project, 2012-2016
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Julita Majczyk
Session VII: Saturday, July 06, 11:00 to 12:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Evaluations and Attention - Room: 50 George Square - G.06
Chair: Alex Bitektine
Daniel Sands
Competition and evaluation: How perceptions of competition affect evaluations in markets
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Matt D. Dallas
Johan Chu and Sung-Chul Noh
Weapons of mass attention direction: Durable dominance in the Korean popular music industry
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Daniel B. Sands
Kevin Curran, Mike Pfarrer, Scott Graffin and Eric Lee
Sharing the spotlight: The positive effects of celebrity spillover
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Johan S. G. Chu & Sung-Chul Noh
Matt D. Dallas, Peter Sheldon and Tracy Wilcox
Awards as meso-level phenomena in social evaluation processes
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Kevin J. Curran, Michael D. Pfarrer, Scott D. Graffin, Eric Y. Lee
Parallel Stream B: Evaluations and Social Responsibility - Room: 50 George Square - G.01
Chair: Patrick Haack
'Alim J. Beveridge and Naidan Zhang
How corporate social responsibility (CSR) attribution is formed and modified: The roles of relational models and CSR cues
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): François Neville
Felix Ostertag, Aline Pündrich and Alicia Prochotta
How digital identity and legitimation strategies affect social ventures’ legitimacy: Insights from two online experiments
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Alim Beveridge & Naidan Zhang
Donald Lange and Helen Hu
Expectations and social evaluations: The subjective meaning of corporate philanthropy
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Felix Ostertag, Aline Pereira Pündrich & Alicia Prochotta
François Neville
The fuzzy logic of social activists: A configurational examination of the corporate opportunity structure for social activism
Discussant(s)Discussant(s): Donald Lange & Helen Hu